Pizza is one of the most popular foods worldwide, with its crispy crust, savory toppings, and melted cheese making it a favorite for many. Over the years, pizza has become a beloved comfort food, eaten in various forms across different cultures. Despite its global popularity, there is an interesting linguistic question that often comes up: why is pizza called a “pie”? While the word “pie” is typically associated with desserts like apple pie or pumpkin pie, pizza—especially in the United States—is frequently referred to as a “pizza pie.” This term, however, is not as universally understood in the same way across the globe. The origins and reasons behind calling pizza a “pie” are tied to historical, cultural, and linguistic factors that have evolved over time. In this article, we will explore the various reasons and historical explanations for why pizza is called a pie.
The Origins of the Term “Pie”
To understand why pizza is referred to as a “pie,” we first need to look at the origins of the word “pie” itself. The term “pie” has roots in Old French and Latin, where it initially referred to any baked dish that had a crust, often filled with various ingredients. In ancient times, pies were made with savory fillings and a crust that acted as both a container and a cooking vessel. This early version of pies did not necessarily have the sweet fillings we associate with pies today but were often filled with meat, vegetables, or even fish.
Over the centuries, the concept of a pie evolved, particularly in Europe. In England, pies became more specialized, often taking the form of a circular or rectangular pastry filled with various ingredients. These savory pies were common in both the aristocratic and common people’s meals. The rise of “sweet pies” like apple pie, which became especially popular in the 17th and 18th centuries, continued to solidify the association of the word “pie” with a baked dish that had a crust and filling.
It is this original use of the word “pie” as a general term for any baked dish with a crust that would eventually lead to pizza being called a “pie” in parts of the world, especially the United States.
Pizza’s Evolution and Adoption of the Term “Pie”
The Birth of Modern Pizza
Modern pizza, as we know it today, has its origins in Naples, Italy, where flatbreads topped with various ingredients were a staple food for the poor. The classic pizza, with its tomato sauce, cheese, and toppings, became popular in Naples during the late 19th century. The introduction of the tomato to Europe from the Americas in the 16th century revolutionized Italian cooking, particularly in Southern Italy, where it became a key ingredient in many dishes. Over time, the tradition of topping flatbreads with tomatoes, cheese, and other ingredients grew and evolved into the dish we recognize today as pizza.
The story of pizza in the United States begins with Italian immigrants who brought their culinary traditions with them during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. In cities like New York, Chicago, and Philadelphia, Italian immigrants began to open pizzerias that served the Neapolitan-style pizza, albeit with their own variations to suit American tastes.
The Emergence of the Term “Pizza Pie”
It is in these early pizzerias, particularly in New York City, that the term “pizza pie” seems to have emerged. The most likely explanation for this is that, as pizza began to gain popularity among American audiences, many people were unfamiliar with the Italian word “pizza” and its specific meaning. The English-speaking American public had more experience with the word “pie,” which was already commonly used to describe dishes that were baked in a round shape and had a crust.
At the time, the concept of a pie was not restricted to sweet fillings but also encompassed savory options like meat pies and pot pies. As pizzerias began to serve pizza in a round, pie-like shape, it was natural for customers to refer to this new Italian dish as a “pizza pie.” The circular shape of the pizza, its doughy crust, and its toppings seemed similar enough to a traditional pie that the term was adopted, especially in the Italian-American community.
The use of “pie” in relation to pizza was further popularized by the American media, including cookbooks and restaurant menus. This helped cement the term “pizza pie” in American lexicon, and it eventually became synonymous with pizza in many parts of the U.S.
Regional Differences in Terminology
While the term “pizza pie” gained widespread use in the United States, it is not commonly used in other parts of the world. In Italy, for example, pizza is simply called “pizza”—there is no reference to “pie.” The difference in terminology reflects the cultural and linguistic distinctions between countries and their culinary practices. In Italy, the word “pie” is typically reserved for sweet pastries like apple pie or tarts, and the savory pizza simply goes by its Italian name.
In contrast, the United States has a long history of blending different cultural influences, particularly through the waves of immigration in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Italian immigrants, who had their own pizza traditions, began to serve pizza to an American audience that was already familiar with pies. This cultural fusion helped propagate the term “pizza pie” in the U.S., even as pizza continued to evolve into its own unique style.
Today, pizza is referred to as a “pie” in many parts of the U.S., especially in places with large Italian-American populations such as New York City, where the term “pizza pie” remains a part of everyday speech.
Cultural Factors Contributing to the Term “Pie”
The term “pizza pie” is not only a linguistic convenience but also a reflection of cultural influences. To understand the adoption of the term more fully, we need to look at the broader cultural context in which pizza became a major food in the United States.
The Influence of Italian-American Cuisine
Italian-American cuisine developed as a result of Italian immigrants adapting their traditional dishes to fit American ingredients and tastes. Pizza, a traditional Italian food, underwent modifications in America to appeal to the local palate. One of the key changes was the adoption of larger, thicker crusts and the addition of more toppings. American pizzas were often much larger than their Italian counterparts, and their round shape resembled the familiar pies that Americans were used to.
The adoption of the term “pizza pie” was likely a way for Italian immigrants to make their dish more relatable to the American public. While pizza was unique to Italy, the idea of a “pie” was universally recognized in the U.S. as a baked dish, making the term accessible and understandable.
Popularization of Pizza in the U.S.
During the mid-20th century, pizza gained immense popularity across the United States, thanks in part to the rise of pizzerias and the development of pizza chains. As more people in the U.S. became familiar with pizza, the term “pizza pie” was further ingrained in popular culture. In addition to pizzerias, pizza was featured in films, television shows, and commercials, reinforcing the association between pizza and the word “pie.”
The rise of the pizza industry in the U.S., with chains like Domino’s, Papa John’s, and Pizza Hut, helped cement pizza’s status as a national dish. As pizza became more mainstream, the term “pie” continued to be used in both casual and formal contexts to describe the dish.
The Enduring Popularity of “Pizza Pie”
Despite the growth of the pizza industry and the spread of pizza worldwide, the term “pizza pie” remains popular, particularly in American culture. In regions like New York and New Jersey, people still commonly refer to a pizza as a “pie,” whether they are ordering from a local pizzeria or making it at home. Even with the advent of new pizza styles like deep dish or thin-crust pizza, the use of the term “pie” remains widespread.
Why Some People Find the Term “Pizza Pie” Confusing
While the term “pizza pie” is widely used in the United States, it can be confusing for those who are unfamiliar with its origins. For one, the word “pie” typically refers to sweet dishes like apple pie or cherry pie, which are baked in a crust. The use of “pie” to describe a savory dish like pizza can seem odd to people who are not familiar with the tradition of calling pizza a “pie.” This has led to some confusion, especially among non-American audiences, who may not fully understand why pizza is associated with the word “pie.”
Additionally, as pizza continues to evolve and adapt to different cultural tastes, the traditional “pizza pie” term may seem outdated or unnecessary. Many pizza lovers, particularly in Italy and other parts of the world, continue to refer to the dish simply as “pizza,” without any reference to “pie.”
Conclusion
The term “pizza pie” has its origins in the cultural and linguistic fusion that took place when Italian immigrants brought pizza to the United States. In a country where pies were already a well-known concept, calling pizza a “pie” made the dish more accessible and relatable to the American public. Over time, the term became entrenched in American culture, particularly in areas with large Italian-American populations.
Today, while the term “pizza pie” is still widely used in the U.S., it remains largely unfamiliar or unused in other parts of the world. Nevertheless, the legacy of calling pizza a “pie” speaks to the adaptability of pizza and the way food can evolve as it moves across cultures. Whether you call it a pizza or a pizza pie, one thing is certain—this beloved dish is here to stay, and its name will continue to evolve alongside its rich history and worldwide popularity.
Related Topics
- Sicilian Pizza VS Neapolitan Pizza: What Is the Difference?
- Where Did Hawaiian Pizza Originate?
- What Are the 5 Most Common Pizza Toppings?
