Barstool’s Dave Portnoy, in one of his popular “One Bite” reviews, offered high praise for Rosie’s Pizza, calling it “unbelievable.” This glowing endorsement came as no surprise, as the small but exceptional pizza shop at the Jersey Shore has quickly made a name for itself.
Founded in 2017, Rosie’s Pizza in Point Pleasant has risen from humble beginnings to become one of the most talked-about eateries on the Shore. In less than eight years, the restaurant has earned significant recognition in a state known for its deep appreciation of pizza.
Last summer, nj.com ranked Rosie’s Pizza as the #2 pizza shop at the Jersey Shore. The same publication also hailed their signature “grandma pie” as one of the best pizzas in the state. Known for its sourdough crust, Rosie’s offers both round and square pies, along with famous meatballs that have become a local staple. The meatballs, available a la carte, are a fan favorite alongside a variety of fresh salads.
Despite its reputation, Rosie’s keeps its menu intentionally simple. The restaurant’s backstory, shared on its website, emphasizes their singular focus on quality: “We’re obsessed with making high-quality pizza, and there’s very little else on the menu to distract from that focus. Years of experience, constant experimentation, and most of all a passion to produce a great product make each and every pizza at Rosie’s special.”
Now, with a loyal following and critical acclaim, Rosie’s is expanding. A second location recently opened in Middletown, bringing the beloved pizzeria to a new community while staying close enough to the original in Point Pleasant Beach to maintain its established name recognition. The new Rosie’s Pizza is located at Kings Common Shopping Plaza, positioned strategically on Route 35 in Middletown, where it is poised to attract a fresh set of pizza enthusiasts.
The expansion marks another success story for a small business that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Rosie’s Pizza, which continues to do everything right, proves that a focus on quality and simplicity can lead to success in an industry where competition is fierce.
As Rosie’s continues to grow, fans can look forward to more of the exceptional pies they’ve come to love—now available in even more locations along the Jersey Shore.
