With so many outstanding pizzerias across South Jersey, choosing the best pizza is no easy feat. From traditional favorites to creative pies that push the boundaries of flavor, the region is home to an array of pizza spots that cater to every taste.
Each year, we take on the challenge of determining the top pizza places in Burlington, Camden, Cumberland, and Gloucester counties. With so many contenders, it’s a true test of which restaurant can master the perfect crust, sauce, cheese-to-topping ratio, and overall flavor. So, which pizzeria will take the crown this year? Let’s take a closer look at the best South Jersey has to offer.
Santucci’s Original Square Pizza, Sewell
A standout in South Jersey for over 60 years, Santucci’s Original Square Pizza in Sewell offers a unique twist on traditional pizza. Unlike most, Santucci’s places the cheese beneath the sauce, giving their pies a distinct texture and flavor. The result is a crispy crust with a soft, gooey interior. Their square-shaped pizzas are a hit, offering a homemade feel that fans find addictive. For those seeking a familiar yet different experience, Santucci’s is a must-try.
Brooklyn Original Pizzeria, Haddon Heights
If you crave the thin, foldable slices reminiscent of New York-style pizza, Brooklyn Original Pizzeria in Haddon Heights delivers. Their pies, like the fan-favorite “Fuggedaboutit,” combine fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, and basil for a simple yet flavorful experience. They also offer pinwheels, rolled slices filled with toppings such as buffalo chicken or chicken ranch. Focused on high-quality ingredients and classic flavors, this pizzeria offers a true Brooklyn experience.
Tacconelli’s Pizzeria, Haddon Township
Tacconelli’s, a beloved establishment since 1946, is known for its thin, crispy pies that are carefully crafted using only the freshest ingredients. With a commitment to quality, Tacconelli’s offers a simple yet delicious tomato pie, with a thin crust and rich tomato sauce as the star. Customers must call ahead to reserve dough, ensuring that only the freshest pizzas are served. Tacconelli’s is a go-to spot for thin-crust lovers looking for authentic, flavorful pizza.
Kate & Al’s Pizza, Columbus
A family-owned favorite in Burlington County, Kate & Al’s has been serving delicious old-school square pizza for decades. Known for their light, crispy crust and flavorful tomato sauce, Kate & Al’s focuses on the basics. The sauce takes center stage, allowing the pizza’s simplicity to shine. This unpretentious pizzeria offers a timeless slice that locals swear by.
Big John’s Pizza, Bridgeton
For those who prefer their pizza big and cheesy, Big John’s in Bridgeton is the place to go. Their oversized pizzas, topped with generous portions of cheese and fresh toppings, are perfect for anyone who believes bigger is better. Big John’s uses fresh daily-made dough, which contributes to their thick, chewy crust. Bold, garlicky sauce and a hefty cheese pull make this pizzeria a crowd-pleaser.
Riccardo’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Browns Mills
Riccardo’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant offers consistency and quality with every pizza they serve. Known for its perfectly baked, thin-crust pies, Riccardo’s combines fresh ingredients with rich, flavorful sauces. Their tomato pies, with the right balance of tangy and slightly sweet sauce, are a standout. With a wide menu of Italian classics, Riccardo’s provides a cozy, family-friendly dining experience that keeps customers coming back.
Luca’s Pizza at The Cumberland Mall, Vineland
Located in Cumberland Mall, Luca’s Pizza proves that great pizza doesn’t need a sit-down restaurant. With hand-tossed dough made fresh daily, Luca’s pizzas offer a perfect mix of crispy and chewy textures. Their zesty tomato sauce and well-balanced cheese make each slice a satisfying treat. Known for their large slices, Luca’s is a great choice when you’re in need of a quick, delicious meal during a shopping trip.
Holy Tomato, Blackwood
Holy Tomato in Blackwood stands out for its creative, specialty pizzas. With unique pies like the Buffalo Chicken and Super Veggie, Holy Tomato offers an inventive approach to traditional pizza. The Buffalo Chicken Pie combines mozzarella, garlic, shredded chicken, and a choice of homemade buffalo sauce, while the Super Veggie Pie features a mix of roasted veggies on a white pizza. Holy Tomato’s funky atmosphere and inventive flavors make it the perfect place for those seeking something different.
Joe’s Pizzeria and Bistro, Marlton
Joe’s Pizzeria and Bistro in Marlton is a standout for both pizza and Italian cuisine. Their thin, crispy pizza features a perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio, while their extensive menu offers pasta, seafood, and sandwiches. Known for their large portions and inviting atmosphere, Joe’s is ideal for a family dinner or a date night. Whether you’re craving pizza or Italian classics, Joe’s delivers both with flair.
Raymond’s Pizza, Cherry Hill
Raymond’s Pizza in Cherry Hill is a classic choice for those who appreciate simplicity and consistency. Their plain cheese pizza is a fan favorite, featuring a perfectly balanced sauce that’s neither too sweet nor too salty. Raymond’s also offers specialty pizzas like their “Swirl” pizza, which adds an extra pop of flavor. For a more diverse menu, they also serve strombolis, calzones, and traditional Italian dishes.
Choosing the Best Pizza in South Jersey
So, who serves the best pizza in South Jersey? The truth is, each of these pizzerias excels in its own way. Whether you’re craving Santucci’s square pies, Brooklyn Original’s foldable slices, or Tacconelli’s classic tomato pies, South Jersey has something for every pizza lover. Visit your favorite spot, grab a slice, and savor the flavors that keep locals coming back year after year.
Which one is your pick for the ultimate slice? The decision is yours.
Related topic:
- Asian Restaurant Brings Malatang Trend to Dallas
- Caprinos Pizza Opens New Branch in Wymondham
- Oakville Pizza Closes After Over Two Decades of Service
