Dave Portnoy, the founder of Barstool Sports, has been reviewing pizzas since 2013 through his popular series, One Bite Pizza Reviews. Known for his straightforward ratings and unique approach, Portnoy evaluates each pizza on several factors: the vibe of the restaurant, the atmosphere, and, most importantly, the quality of the pizza itself.
His ratings typically range from 6.0 to 7.0 for average pizzas, but there are a select few in New Hampshire that have earned scores of 7.6 or higher. Here’s a look at the top three pizza spots that impressed Portnoy the most.
1. The Ricochet – Derry, NH (Score: 7.7)
The Ricochet, located at 35 Manchester Rd., stands as the highest-rated pizza restaurant in New Hampshire according to Portnoy. He praised the restaurant’s great atmosphere, noting the friendly owners who had an inspiring story of escaping the California wildfires and rebuilding their lives in New England. The name “Ricochet” symbolizes their journey, and Portnoy was clearly impressed by their resilience. “I like it,” Portnoy remarked, giving the spot an impressive score of 7.7.
2. Mickey’s N.Y. Pizza – Crystal Ave., NH (Score: 7.6)
Mickey’s N.Y. Pizza, located at 9 Crystal Ave., also earned a solid 7.6 rating. Portnoy noted the clear attention to detail, with instructions posted around the kitchen about how he likes his pizza. Though he described it as “really standard, good pizza,” he emphasized that it gets the job done. “They’re not going to write songs and poems about it, but it’s good,” Portnoy commented, reflecting a no-nonsense, reliable pizza experience.
3. Kelsen Brewing Company – Nashua Rd., NH (Score: 7.6)
Tied for second place, Kelsen Brewing Company, located at 44 Nashua Rd., earned a 7.6 rating from Portnoy. He didn’t elaborate much but described it as a good, local spot offering “good quality pizza.” Portnoy seemed to appreciate its convenience, particularly if you’re in the area and craving a solid pizza.
These three New Hampshire pizza joints are the standout winners in Portnoy’s book, each offering something unique to satisfy pizza lovers. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, these spots are worth a visit for a slice that delivers.
Related topic:
- Asian Restaurant Brings Malatang Trend to Dallas
- Caprinos Pizza Opens New Branch in Wymondham
- Oakville Pizza Closes After Over Two Decades of Service
