Five Chicago pizzerias have been recognized as some of the best in the Midwest, according to a new Yelp ranking. Among them, Pequod’s Pizza and Milly’s Pizza in the Pan secured spots in the top five.
Yelp’s recent list features five Chicago establishments that stand out for their exceptional pizza offerings. Pequod’s Pizza ranks third, while Milly’s Pizza in the Pan takes the fifth spot. Other Chicago pizzerias making the list include Zazas Pizzeria at No. 12, Forno Rosso Pizzeria Napoletana at No. 30, and George’s Deep Dish at No. 41.
Illinois and Michigan are the most represented states on the list, highlighting their strong pizza culture. Yelp praised Pequod’s Pizza, noting its unique caramelized cheese crust, created by pressing mozzarella between the dough and baking it in a special pan until it becomes dark and bubbly.
Milly’s Pizza in the Pan was celebrated for its fresh ingredients and commitment to quality, which consistently earns praise from customers.
Loui’s Pizza in Hazel Park, Michigan, claimed the top spot on Yelp’s list for its exceptional Detroit-style pies, while Futuro in Indianapolis ranked second.
The full list showcases a variety of pizza styles, with Chicago’s contributions further cementing the city’s reputation as a pizza powerhouse in the Midwest.
Top 10 Pizza Spots in the Midwest:
Loui’s Pizza, Hazel Park, Michigan
Futuro, Indianapolis, Indiana
Pequod’s Pizza, Chicago, Illinois
Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery, Reynoldsburg, Ohio
Milly’s Pizza in the Pan, Chicago, Illinois
In Forno Pizza, Avon, Ohio
Pizzeoli Wood Fired Pizza, St. Louis, Missouri
Brittany’s Brick Oven Pizza, Madison, Indiana
Dough Daddy’s Pizza, Westmont, Illinois
Tasty Pizza, Omaha, Nebraska
The list continues to rank pizza spots across the Midwest, with Chicago’s Zazas Pizzeria, Forno Rosso Pizzeria Napoletana, and George’s Deep Dish making strong showings, solidifying Chicago’s dominance in the regional pizza scene.
